‘Teaming’ In and Out of City Hall

July 17, 2019
Amy Edmondson teaching

‘Teaming’ In and Out of City Hall

July 17, 2019
Amy Edmondson teaching

‘Teaming’ In and Out of City Hall

July 17, 2019

This article was originally published on July 17, 2019 on the Bloomberg Cities blog. Find the original article here.

All mayors have their trusted advisers, department leaders, and senior staff—the core team who keeps City Hall running, day in and day out.

If every mayor has a team, however, not all are adept at “teaming.” That’s a dynamic activity, where you’re pulling together people from different backgrounds to diagnose a problem, learn quickly, and work together to find solutions. Teaming is a critical public leadership tool, whether you need to solve urgent problems quickly or to seek breakthrough innovations to address complex urban challenges over time. And as I discussed this week with the 41 mayors starting a year-long leadership and management program with the Bloomberg Harvard City Leadership Initiative, it’s a skill they and their senior leadership want to get better at.

As we seek to better understand the role of teaming in addressing the complex social issues facing mayors and their cities every day, my Harvard colleagues, Hannah Riley-Bowles, Jorrit de Jong, Eva Flavia Martinez Orbegozo, and I have launched new research as part of the Bloomberg Harvard program. Through new analysis of work in cities, we are seeking to observe and identify the enablers of and barriers to successful cross-boundary teaming in cities.

What’s the difference between a team and teaming? In short, “team” is a noun—a group with fixed membership. “Teaming” is a verb—it’s something you do on the fly.

Think in terms of basketball.

The Golden State Warriors are a team—a group of individuals who always play on the same side. They learn their plays, get synced up on strategy, and grow accustomed to each other’s style of play. And the team is their full-time job, so they have plenty of time to practice together.

Teaming is like a pickup game—individuals from different backgrounds, coming together to play for a short time. They may not know each other at all, let alone one another’s strengths and weaknesses at basketball. They need to get up to speed quickly, and be adaptable, to succeed.

Outside of sports, working in teams is common—and government is no exception. There are good reasons for that. Well-led teams develop a shared sense of purpose that supports their everyday work. Members become familiar with each other, both as people and as professionals, and learn whose skills can be useful to the group. They also can establish a common language for situations they encounter and develop preferred ways of resolving conflict and holding each other accountable.

However, teams often might not be practical for fighting drug addiction, improving schools, or solving many of the complex problems common in cities. Innovation in this setting requires convening multiple perspectives—often from across city agencies or from partners in the nonprofit, business, university, and philanthropy sectors—to look at things from different vantage points and work together to discover new solutions. The people brought together to innovate already have other roles and responsibilities—and aren’t expected to stop what they’re doing to join a new team full time. Rather, they are asked to contribute ideas and skills and to be willing to help test and implement new possibilities. Different expertise will be needed at different times—and often in ways that are impossible to anticipate in advance. That’s a perfect setting for teaming: when you need different sets of expertise, skills, and resources, at unpredictable times, to get things done.

This can be a lot harder than it sounds. Just as it may take a pickup basketball team a while to find a groove, it takes cross-agency or cross-sector teams time to get on the same page. Put a police captain, housing officer, and social worker together to work on homelessness, and each will likely come with his or her own assumptions about what changes are needed, and each brings his or her own language or jargon for describing them. Logistics are also a challenge—everything from finding a time and location for people to meet when needed, to figuring out how to conduct research, share expertise, design experiments, and consolidate learnings. Those issues can be tricky when people are operating outside their normal hierarchy.

To address these issues, you need a good team leader—someone to own the mission, organize meetings, keep the attention of those contributing to the initiative, and ultimately deliver its results. In the city government context, that person is often in city hall, ideally close to the mayor’s office, where the authority to convene cross-agency and cross-sector partnerships is clear.

What else is needed for effective teaming? After studying examples from across many industries, I’ve seen four key practices emerge. (For more on each, read my Harvard Business Review article, “Wicked Problem Solvers”):

teaming.png

Teaming requires an adaptable vision. This means providing space for team members to shape and influence where the project goes, acknowledging pivots when they happen—all the while remaining true to the underlying values of the project.

Teaming needs psychological safety. Team members need to feel safe voicing ideas, even if those ideas might seem obvious to other team members with more issue-area expertise. They need to believe their thoughts are welcome in the teaming arena. Everyone’s ability to maintain curiosity and an open mind is key.

Knowledge sharing across silos has to be facilitated. Pulling in expertise from different fields is the point. Making sure those diverse perspectives are heard and understood takes effort—because this doesn’t happen automatically.

Teaming requires experimenting and learning. The process is necessarily iterative. In a collaboration designed to come up with brand new solutions, there’s obviously no blueprint to follow. It’s crucial to be willing to put new ideas to a test, so as to learn quickly and keep going, or else adapt and try again.

These four practices exist in subtle, and occasionally striking, contrast to the management of conventional project teams. The table below lays out the differences between teaming practices with those of conventional project management.

And that gets us to one way in which teaming is not like pickup basketball. Where a pickup game might feel loose, informal, or unstructured, teaming well requires a good bit of intention. It’s messy but disciplined. It’s an unpredictable but structured learning process. Teaming involves bringing people together in a deliberate and thoughtful way, so that their diverse experiences can lead the group to see a problem in an entirely new way.

Amy C. Edmondson is the Novartis Professor of Leadership and Management at the Harvard Business School, a chair established to support the study of human interactions that lead to the creation of successful enterprises that contribute to the betterment of society. Her books include "Teaming: How organizations learn, innovate and compete in the knowledge economy", and ”The Fearless Organization: Creating Psychological Safety in the Workplace for Learning, Innovation and Growth.”

Twenty-two Harvard graduate students take their talents to U.S. and international cities

June 10, 2022, Cambridge, Massachusetts: The Bloomberg Harvard City Leadership Initiative, the flagship program of the Bloomberg Center for Cities, is pleased to announce the 2022 Bloomberg Harvard Summer Fellows. This group of 22 outstanding Harvard Master’s and professional degree students was selected from a highly capable pool of more than 150 applicants from across nine Harvard Schools.

Briana Acosta
Briana Acosta
Kitchener, Canada
Building Resilience: Supporting Youth Mental Health Post-Pandemic
Larisa Barreto
Larisa Barreto
San Juan, PR
Improving Trash Collection Services
Virginia Carefoote
Virginia Carefoote
Salt Lake City, UT
Public Private Partnership Neighborhood Development
Liz Cormack
Liz Cormack
Kansas City, MO
Mapping the Journey Back to the Community After Incarceration

Students will work in local government in the following cities, all recent participants in the Initiative’s programming for mayors and senior city leaders:

  • Amarillo, Texas
  • Baltimore, Maryland
  • Bogotá, Colombia
  • Brownsville, Texas
  • Chattanooga, Tennessee
  • Green Bay, Wisconsin
  • Hampton, Virginia
  • Honolulu, Hawaii
  • Islip, New York
  • Kansas City, Missouri
  • Kitchener, Canada
  • Moncton, Canada
  • Pomona, California
  • Portsmouth, Virginia
  • Riga, Latvia
  • Salt Lake City, Utah
  • San Juan, Puerto Rico (two Fellows)
  • Savannah, Georgia
  • Scranton, Pennsylvania
  • Scottsdale, Arizona
  • Tshwane, South Africa


They will contribute meaningfully to innovating government services, applying the tools of data-driven decision-making, human-centered design, and cross-sector collaboration to help cities tackle complex challenges such as gun violence, youth mental health, equitable economic development, and homelessness, improving the lives of city residents.

Paul Dingus
Paul Dingus
Tshwane, South Africa
Building a Citizen Relations Platform To Improve Oversight and Transparency With Residents
Isabel Mejia Fontanot
Isabel Mejia Fontanot
San Juan, PR
Improving Trash Collection Services
Hayley Glatter
Hayley Glatter
Islip, NY
Activating Regional Aviation: Crafting a Marketing Strategy for Long Island MacArthur Airport
Ryan Herman
Ryan Herman
Amarillo, TX
Analyzing the Root Causes of Gun Violence to Create a Starting Point in Combating the Issue

Since 2018, the Initiative has placed 86 Harvard graduate students in paid summer roles in 59 U.S. cities and nine international cities (some with multiple placements). Fellows work closely with city leader supervisors, addressing complex problems such as affordable housing, community safety, early childhood development, equitable economic recovery, and racial equity and access. Fellows deliver work such as analyses, plan designs, and new resources to assist mayors and city staff in advancing key priorities.

Sohee Hyung
Sohee Hyung
Brownsville, TX
Shaping a New Economic Ecosystem: Gap Analysis for Brownsville’s NewSpace City
Wladka Kijewska
Władka Kijewska
Riga, Latvia
Spreading Joy in the Public Realm: Crafting an Urban Design Placemaking Plan
Jacob Metz
Jacob Metz
Green Bay, WI
Increasing Supplier Diversity, Procurement, and Contracting
Abdurrehman Naveed
Abdurrehman Naveed
Honolulu, HI
Assessing the Impact of Fiscal Policies on City Hiring Practices

This year’s class of Summer Fellows includes 12 graduate students from Harvard Kennedy School (HKS), four from the Harvard Graduate School of Design, two from the Harvard Graduate School of Education, one from the Harvard Divinity School, and one earning a joint degree at HKS and Yale Law School.

Jiwon Park
Jiwon Park
Moncton, Canada
Improving Social Amenities Through Coordinated Community Development and Municipal Planning
Jess Redmond
Jess Redmond
Scranton, PA
Expanding Economic Opportunity for Residents and Business Owners
Naomi Robalino
Naomi Robalino
Pomona, CA
Engage Pomona
Nicah Santos
Nicah Santos
Portsmouth, VA
A Whole Community Approach to Reducing Youth Gun Violence
Kacey Short
Kacey Short
Scottsdale, AZ
Increasing Engagement with Young Adults and Persons of Color in Scottsdale

“Summer Fellows are catalysts and emerging leaders,” said Pascha McTyson, the Initiative’s Program Manager for Student Engagement. “The Fellowship is beneficial to everyone—the students who apply their skills and capabilities and gain valuable exposure, and the cities that gain extra capacity and new knowledge and tools to innovate and serve their residents.”

Elena Sokoloski
Elena Sokoloski
Hampton, VA
Reimagining Public Safety: Analyzing Data to Provide Proactive, Effective, and Efficient Service Delivery
Kenashia Thompson
Kenashia Thompson
Savannah, GA
Holistic Approaches to Improving Public Safety
Brett Turner
Brett Turner
Chattanooga, TN
Understanding How Many People Are Experiencing Chronic Homelessness and Their Needs
Cina Vazir
Cina Vazir
Bogotá, Columbia
Evaluating Higher Education Conditional Cash Transfer Programs
Emma Winiski
Emma Winiski
Baltimore, MD
OpioidStat

Seven emerging leaders take up new roles in US cities

August 4, 2022, Cambridge, Massachusetts: The Bloomberg Harvard City Leadership Initiative, the flagship program of the Bloomberg Center for Cities, is pleased to announce the first recipients of the Bloomberg Harvard City Hall Fellowship. Seven accomplished Harvard graduates have accepted positions in city halls around the country, where they will make significant contributions over the next two years.

The City Hall Fellows are working in these cities, which have participated in the Initiative’s programming for mayors and senior city leaders:

  • Boise, Idaho
  • Pueblo, Colorado
  • Charleston, South Carolina
  • Springfield, Illinois
  • Grand Rapids, Michigan
  • Syracuse, New York
  • Knoxville, Tennessee

The Bloomberg Harvard City Hall Fellowship places Harvard master’s or professional degree graduates into leadership positions in city halls, where they will contribute to lasting change by applying skills and helping build capabilities in city government. The Fellows will help their host cities tackle pressing and significant challenges identified by each mayor. Central to each Fellow’s work will be strengthening their host city’s capacity to sustain the work beyond the two-year fellowship term.

The inaugural class of City Hall Fellows includes three master’s degree graduates of Harvard Kennedy School, two from the Harvard Graduate School of Design, and two from the Harvard Graduate School of Education.

“I’m delighted by the knowledge and energy of this inaugural group of talented professionals,” said Bulbul Kaul, the Initiative’s Senior Program Director for City Support and Student Engagement. “The City Hall Fellows will take on complex challenges that are top priorities for each city’s leadership, ones that will benefit from fresh perspectives, new uses of data, and collaborative and innovative approaches to help diagnose and address the underlying causes and symptoms. We look forward to the cities’ future progress and accomplishments, achieved with their Fellows’ contributions over the next two years.”

The City Hall Fellowship team is planning future cohorts and will invite potential host cities to apply in fall 2022. Fellowship applications will open to eligible Harvard graduate students at that time, and the Initiative will announce the second annual cohort of Fellows in summer 2023, following a competitive application process. Fellows receive a competitive salary and benefits, robust professional development opportunities, and a unique opportunity to make a difference in people’s lives.

Visit our Fellowships page and join our email list to get the latest information.